Solid Form Screening and Selection

Solid Form Screening and Selection

BOC Sciences provides solid form screening and selection services that help drug discovery and development teams characterize the crystalline and amorphous landscape of their compounds, compare polymorphs, salts, cocrystals, and amorphous forms, and select a lead solid form that balances solubility, stability, and manufacturability. Our work connects early in vitro solubility behavior with crystallization science, structural characterization, and downstream process thinking, so that form decisions are supported by data rather than assumption.

What is Solid Form Screening and Why does Form Selection Matter?

A solid form is the physical state in which a compound exists as a solid, defined by its molecular packing, crystallinity, hydration, and ionization state. The same molecule can adopt multiple solid forms, including polymorphs, salts, cocrystals, solvates, hydrates, and amorphous solids, each with distinct physicochemical behavior. Solid form screening is the systematic search, preparation, and characterization of these forms to build a complete landscape, while form selection chooses the lead form that best supports the intended product profile. Form selection matters because it directly influences dissolution, exposure, chemical and physical stability, hygroscopicity, powder flow, and filterability, and it also shapes intellectual property options. Choosing the wrong form late in development can force costly rework, whereas identifying a stable, performant form early reduces downstream risk. BOC Sciences supports teams across discovery, lead optimization, and early development stages with tiered screening that scales with material availability and project urgency.

BOC Sciences Solid Form Screening and Selection Services

Polymorph Screening

We map the crystalline form landscape of free forms, salts, or cocrystals by varying the conditions that govern nucleation, growth, and solid-state conversion.

  • Screen Design: Solvent class, water activity, temperature, concentration, supersaturation, cooling rate, agitation, seeding, and aging conditions.
  • Form Generation: Cooling, evaporation, antisolvent addition, slurry conversion, vapor diffusion, temperature cycling, grinding, and recrystallization.
  • Characterization: XRPD, DSC, TGA, DVS, PLM, spectroscopy, water content, residual solvent, and solution-mediated transformation studies.
  • Selection Outputs: Distinct-form inventory, duplicate-pattern removal, relative stability relationships, conversion risks, and recommended polymorphs for further evaluation.

Salt Screening

For ionizable compounds, BOC Sciences evaluates counterions and crystallization conditions to identify salt candidates with useful solid-state and biopharmaceutical properties.

  • Candidate Design: Review of ionizable groups, pKa relationships, stoichiometry, counterion class, solvent compatibility, and free-form limitations.
  • Salt Generation: Solution, slurry, antisolvent, reactive crystallization, evaporation, cooling, and mechanochemical approaches across selected counterions.
  • Confirmation: XRPD, thermal analysis, spectroscopy, stoichiometric review, and counterion analysis to distinguish salts from mixtures or free forms.
  • Selection Outputs: Comparison of crystallinity, solubility, hygroscopicity, stability, salt disproportionation risk, powder behavior, and preparation reproducibility.

Cocrystal Screening

Cocrystal screening provides an alternative route for neutral, weakly ionizable, or salt-forming compounds whose available forms do not meet target property needs.

  • Coformer Strategy: Selection based on hydrogen-bonding motifs, molecular complementarity, pKa relationships, physicochemical properties, and intended application.
  • Generation Methods: Solvent evaporation, cooling, slurry conversion, antisolvent crystallization, liquid-assisted grinding, neat grinding, and controlled stoichiometric variation.
  • Form Assignment: XRPD fingerprinting, DSC, TGA, spectroscopy, stoichiometry, and single-crystal or solid-state NMR support when needed.
  • Selection Outputs: Coformer hit list, solid-form classification, conversion behavior, solubility and moisture response, and comparative development recommendations.

Amorphous Form Screening

We assess whether an amorphous form can provide a useful performance advantage and whether that advantage can be maintained against recrystallization.

  • Feasibility Assessment: Crystallization tendency, glass transition behavior, amorphous solubility, thermal history, moisture sensitivity, and recrystallization pathways.
  • Preparation Methods: Spray drying, solvent evaporation, freeze drying, melt quenching, milling, and other compound-compatible amorphization approaches.
  • Stabilization Screening: Polymer compatibility studies using HPMC, PVP, copovidone, and other matrix formers when neat amorphous material is insufficiently stable.
  • Selection Outputs: Amorphous-form feasibility, crystallinity limits, polymer shortlist, storage-risk map, dissolution behavior, and recommendations for further formulation work.
Need a Solid Form Strategy for a Challenging Compound?

Share your molecular structure, available material, ionization profile, known forms, solubility limitations, target dosage form, and current processing challenge. BOC Sciences will design a focused plan covering form generation, characterization, comparative testing, and selection.

Request a Screening Plan

Key Solid Form Selection Criteria We Evaluate

Physicochemical stability assessment

Physicochemical Stability Assessment

  • Physical stability under temperature, humidity, light, solvent vapor, and mechanical stress.
  • Thermal transitions, melting, desolvation, dehydration, glass transition, and decomposition behavior by thermal analysis.
  • Chemical integrity and degradation trends using suitable chromatographic methods.
  • Risk of polymorphic conversion, hydration, solvation, amorphous recrystallization, or salt disproportionation during stability studies.
Biopharmaceutical performance assessment

Biopharmaceutical Performance Assessment

  • Thermodynamic, kinetic, intrinsic, and pH-dependent solubility analysis for candidate forms.
  • Comparative dissolution testing, supersaturation behavior, precipitation tendency, and solution-mediated form conversion.
  • BCS-informed interpretation using solubility, dissolution, and available permeability and partition data.
  • Selection of forms that offer a practical performance advantage without introducing unacceptable physical instability.
Processing and manufacturing performance assessment

Processing and Manufacturing Performance Assessment

  • Crystallinity, crystal habit, agglomeration state, bulk and tapped density, and particle size distribution.
  • Flowability, cohesion, electrostatic charging, wall adhesion, compactability, and other mechanical properties.
  • Filterability, wash efficiency, drying behavior, milling response, and sensitivity to compaction or shear.
  • Reproducibility of the target form across preparation batches and process-relevant condition ranges.
Integrated developability and risk assessment

Integrated Developability and Risk Assessment

  • Multi-attribute comparison of stability, solubility, dissolution, hygroscopicity, powder behavior, and preparation feasibility.
  • Risk ranking of metastable forms, hydrates, solvates, amorphous content, disproportionation, and process-induced transformations.
  • Alignment of form properties with the intended route, dosage-form concept, and preformulation screening needs.
  • Decision matrix, recommended lead and backup forms, supporting evidence, and prioritized follow-up experiments.

Key Solid Form Characterization Technologies We Support

Solid form assignment and selection require complementary methods. BOC Sciences combines structural, thermal, moisture, microscopic, spectroscopic, and performance measurements so that a candidate is not advanced on the basis of one signal alone.

TechnologyPrimary Use in Solid Form Studies
X-ray Powder Diffraction (XRPD)Provides a characteristic diffraction fingerprint for phase identification, form comparison, mixture review, crystallinity assessment, and monitoring of transformations under selected conditions.
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)Measures melting, glass transition, crystallization, desolvation, and solid-solid transitions, supporting interpretation of polymorphic relationships and amorphous behavior.
Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA)Tracks temperature-dependent mass loss to investigate water or solvent content, desolvation and dehydration events, and thermal decomposition.
Dynamic Vapor Sorption (DVS)Measures moisture sorption and desorption across controlled relative humidity to support hygroscopicity testing, hydrate-risk assessment, and amorphous-form evaluation.
Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM)Visualizes crystal habit, particle morphology, agglomeration, and birefringence; hot-stage microscopy can help relate visible changes to thermal events.
Solid-State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (ssNMR)Provides local molecular-environment information that complements diffraction and spectroscopy for polymorph differentiation, amorphous-content review, and salt or cocrystal confirmation.
Solubility and Dissolution MeasurementsCompare equilibrium behavior, dissolution rate, supersaturation, precipitation, and solution-mediated conversion to determine whether a form offers a useful performance advantage.
A Screening Scope Matched to Your Available Material

BOC Sciences can begin with a material-sparing risk screen or design a broader landscape study. Experimental depth, analytical escalation, and candidate testing are adjusted as evidence develops, helping direct material toward the forms and questions that matter most.

Discuss Your Compound

Our Solid Form Screening and Selection Workflow

Project consultation

1High-Throughput Screening Design and Form Generation

We design crystallization arrays spanning solvent, anti-solvent, temperature, pH, and seeding conditions, then generate forms using cooling, evaporation, slurry, and precipitation routes. Recrystallization and solvent-exchange triage help maximize form diversity from limited material.

Form characterization

2Rapid Characterization and Form Classification

Each solid is profiled by XRPD, DSC, Raman, and microscopy to classify forms, detect amorphous content, and group identical materials, building a reliable form inventory for downstream comparison.

Property and developability assessment

3Candidate Property and Developability Assessment

Candidate forms are compared for solubility, dissolution, stability, hygroscopicity, and processing behavior, then ranked against the target product profile to narrow the field to a few defensible options.

Lead form selection and scale-up

4Lead Form Selection and Scale-Up Verification

We nominate a lead form with clear rationale and verify reproducibility through a baseline crystallization route, with scale-up checks to confirm the form can be made consistently at larger quantities.

Common Solid Form Challenges We Help Clients Solve

01

Incomplete or Uncertain Solid Form Landscapes

A limited solvent screen may repeatedly recover the supplied material while missing metastable polymorphs, hydrates, solvates, or process-induced forms. BOC Sciences expands the relevant experimental space using solvent-diversity design, multiple crystallization routes, water-activity variation, temperature cycling, slurry conversion, seeding, and mechanical stress. XRPD clustering and orthogonal analysis distinguish genuine forms from duplicates, mixtures, desolvated products, and crystallinity differences, producing a clearer landscape and a risk-ranked plan for further work.

02

Poor Solubility or Dissolution of Stable Forms

The thermodynamically stable polymorph may offer excellent physical stability but insufficient solubility or slow dissolution. We compare free forms, salts, cocrystals, metastable crystalline forms, and amorphous options while monitoring whether apparent solubility gains are lost through precipitation or solution-mediated conversion. When solid form modification alone cannot meet the target, results can guide solubility improvement and formulation strategies that preserve an acceptable balance between performance and stability.

03

Moisture- and Solvent-Driven Phase Transformations

Hydrates, solvates, amorphous materials, and some salts can transform when exposed to water activity, drying conditions, solvent residues, or formulation environments. We combine DVS, controlled-humidity exposure, TGA, DSC, XRPD, Karl Fischer water testing, and residual solvent analysis to identify transition boundaries and conversion pathways. These data support selection of a more robust form and define practical controls for isolation, drying, milling, handling, and storage studies.

04

Trade-Offs Among Stability, Performance, and Processability

The most stable form is not automatically the most useful. A stable crystal may dissolve slowly, a soluble salt may be hygroscopic, and a rapidly dissolving amorphous form may recrystallize. BOC Sciences uses multi-attribute ranking to compare stability, solubility, dissolution, moisture response, morphology, electrostatic behavior, flow, compactability, and preparation feasibility. This makes the selection rationale transparent and allows teams to choose a lead form that matches the real formulation and process priorities.

Turn Solid-State Complexity into a Defensible Form Decision

Collaborate with BOC Sciences to map solid-form diversity, characterize phase relationships, compare development attributes, identify transformation risks, and establish a reproducible path toward the form best suited to your compound and application.

Request a Quote

Why Choose Our Solid Form Screening Services?

Multi-Attribute Form Selection for Diverse Project Needs

BOC Sciences evaluates each form against the attributes that matter for the intended program, including physical stability, solubility, dissolution, hygroscopicity, particle behavior, preparation reproducibility, and formulation compatibility. Weighted comparison prevents a single attractive measurement from masking a critical weakness and supports a selection decision that reflects the compound's complete developability profile.

Early Risk Identification to Reduce Late-Stage Failure

Diverse crystallization conditions, stress studies, phase-relation experiments, and process-relevant testing are used to expose hydrate formation, salt disproportionation, amorphous recrystallization, metastable conversion, and mechanically induced changes before a process is built around the wrong form. Early evidence can reduce repeated formulation work, unexpected batch behavior, and costly changes after material requirements have increased.

Novel Solid Form Discovery for Patent Strategy Support

Expanded polymorph, salt, and cocrystal studies can uncover forms with distinct structures and property profiles. BOC Sciences generates reproducible preparation procedures and orthogonal data packages covering identity, composition, thermal behavior, stability, and comparative performance. These scientific records can support evaluation by the client's patent specialists, while novelty, patentability, claim scope, and freedom to operate remain legal determinations.

End-to-End Support from Screening to Scale-Up

Our support can connect starting-material assessment, form generation, rapid triage, advanced characterization, property comparison, crystallization development, scale-up verification, and downstream formulation services. Maintaining one technical thread across these stages helps preserve the rationale behind form selection and enables new data to be interpreted against the original screening landscape.

Applications Supported by Solid Form Screening and Selection

Small-Molecule Drug Substance Development

  • Small-molecule API development and candidate comparison
  • Free-form, salt, cocrystal, hydrate, solvate, and polymorph assessment
  • Starting-material and batch-to-batch form identification
  • Lead and backup solid-form selection
  • Solid-form landscape expansion for technical risk assessment

Preformulation and Formulation Strategy

  • Formulation design and screening guided by solid-state behavior
  • Oral solid dose form selection and powder-property support
  • Suspension, dispersion, and supersaturation risk assessment
  • Excipient- and moisture-driven form-conversion studies
  • Amorphous-form and polymer-stabilization feasibility

Crystallization Process Development and Material Control

  • Solvent-system, seeding, and supersaturation design
  • Cooling, antisolvent, slurry, and reactive crystallization development
  • Filtration, washing, drying, and milling condition assessment
  • Process optimization for form consistency and particle attributes
  • Preparation reproducibility and material-control strategy

Solid Form Screening and Selection Case Studies

Client Needs: A discovery team had a weakly basic heteroaromatic kinase inhibitor with variable XRPD patterns across synthesis batches. The team needed a physically stable crystalline form with reproducible preparation and acceptable dissolution for oral formulation research.

Challenges: The supplied solid contained two closely related patterns, formed a hydrate in water-rich media, and partially converted during drying. The apparent stable form also showed slower dissolution than the mixed starting material.

Solution: We designed 48 crystallization experiments covering cooling, evaporation, antisolvent addition, slurry conversion, and temperature cycling across 14 solvent systems. XRPD clustering separated four reproducible patterns. DSC, TGA, DVS, variable-temperature XRPD, and competitive slurry studies established relative stability and hydrate-conversion pathways. The selected anhydrous form was then reproduced at larger laboratory scale and monitored during filtration, drying, and milling.

Outcome: The study identified a thermodynamically stable anhydrous polymorph, defined conditions that avoided hydrate formation, and established a reproducible preparation route with consistent physical stability.

Client Needs: An oral formulation group needed a salt form of a poorly soluble basic compound that combined improved aqueous behavior with manageable powder flow and low wall adhesion during blending.

Challenges: Early salt hits were crystalline but differed markedly in hygroscopicity, needle formation, electrostatic charging, and filterability. The most soluble hit adhered strongly to stainless-steel surfaces and formed cohesive agglomerates.

Solution: We screened 12 counterions and generated salt candidates by cooling, antisolvent, and slurry methods. XRPD and ion analysis confirmed salt identity, while DSC, TGA, DVS, microscopy, particle sizing, shear-cell flow testing, and charge-to-mass measurements compared powder behavior. Two lead salts were recrystallized under adjusted supersaturation and cooling profiles, and the lower-charging form was verified in a small-scale excipient blending study.

Outcome: A crystalline salt with lower charging tendency, improved handling, and suitable solubility was selected, reducing wall adhesion and simplifying subsequent oral formulation experiments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions illustration

Still have questions?

Contact Us

Client Feedback on Solid Form Screening Projects

Expert Services Supporting Formulation Design and Screening

Have a Question or Issue?

If you have any questions or encounter issues on this page, please don't hesitate to reach out. Our support team is ready to assist you.

Online Inquiry
Verification code